“My anger and disappointment, shared by Catholics and others, are only heightened by the reality that leaders who have engaged in or neglected to protect others from such damaging and deviant behavior have for many years failed to be held accountable — and have even risen in leadership positions,” he said. “We must do better — for the sake of all victims and survivors of sexual abuse and for the sake of everyone whom we serve.”
Gregory said Catholics everywhere, including him, “are stunned and justifiably angry at shameful, unrelenting recent revelations of bishops accused of abuse or mishandling allegations of abuse — behavior that offends and scandalizes the people of God entrusted to our care.”
He said Catholics are specifically “enraged” about allegations of abuse by Archbishop Theodore E. McCarrick and find “any pastoral negligence in protecting our people is similarly grievous.”
“We are weary of this cloud of shame that continues to shroud Church leadership and compromise our mission,” he said, adding that he is “personally disheartened” because in 2002, as president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, he made assurances that this crisis was over and would not be repeated.
“I sincerely believed that the unprecedented steps we took at that time would help to heal this wound in the body of Christ. And so they have,” he added, “though obviously not completely or even sufficiently.”
The archbishop said he was saddened because many good priests are again “seen as suspect not because they have done anything wrong,” and he was hurt that his respect and fraternal esteem for Archbishop McCarrick “were clearly misplaced.”
He said he never personally worked with McCarrick in any pastoral context and said he also “never knew or suspected the hidden side of a man whose admired public persona concealed that of a violator of foundational Christian morality and of young people who trusted him.”
“Like any individual who discovers far too late that a friend has a history of moral misconduct, I now stand dumbfounded that I was so unaware and naive,” he said, adding that he knows many other bishops feel the same way.
“People are angry, as well they should be, that our Church is once again viewed as a haven for criminal deviant behavior,” he said, adding that priests also are hurt and Catholics are disappointed with bishops in general “who seemingly cannot or will not act decisively to heal this festering wound.”
Catholics are “perplexed and sickened,” he said, “that the Holy See may well have dismissed multiple warning signs” that should have stopped McCarrick and others earlier in their careers. He also said Catholics are disheartened that situations here and in other countries continue to “call into question everything the Church has done to safeguard children and adults from manipulation and violation.”
Gregory said he recently met with archdiocesan seminarians and told them directly “that if any person in any context made advances or exhibited behavior that made them feel uncomfortable or threatened, they are to notify the director of vocations, one of the auxiliary bishops or me personally so that we may take swift and appropriate action — pastoral and legal.”
“Their parents and family members should know that these young men are in safe and respectful environments and that, as their archbishop, I will not tolerate any activity that threatens to harm or intimidate them.”
He said that while the USCCB’s current leadership considers its next steps, he strongly urges these leaders to “engage the laity in reviewing and recommending courses of action that will assure the faithful that we are serious in curing this blight from our Church and from episcopal governance once and for all.”
He pointed out that when the USCCB established a national lay review board in 2002, there was some pushback because some people felt they were “improperly ceding control of the ministry of bishops” but given the current situation, he said, oversight by laity “may well provide the only credible assurance that real and decisive actions are being taken.”
“Our trustworthiness as bishops has been so seriously compromised that acting alone — even with the best of intentions and the highest principles, policies and plans –may not move the hearts of the faithful to believe,” he added.
The archbishop said he prays that this moment and the days, weeks, and months ahead will be an opportunity for light to break through the darkness; for victims and survivors of sexual abuse to come forward and receive the help, support and healing they need; and for Church leadership to be renewed and have the courage to take the necessary next steps.
“Like so many of you I am angry, but I am not overcome by despair. I hope and I pray that the Holy Spirit will cleanse and strengthen the Church,” Gregory said. “My anger has not led me to hopelessness; I pray yours has not either. I am grateful for your witness of faith and hope, even in difficult times.”