ROME — The head of the Vatican Secretariat for the Economy said he hopes efforts at financial transparency and reform will foster Catholics’ trust ahead of the annual Peter’s Pence collection.
In an interview with Vatican News June 25, Jesuit Father Juan Antonio Guerrero Alves, prefect of the Secretariat for the Economy, said Catholics “have the right to know how we spend the money given to us.”
“Sometimes contradictions arise from a lack of knowledge, which, in turn, comes from a lack of transparency,” Guerrero said.
Peter’s Pence is a papal fund used for charity, but also to support the running of the Roman Curia and Vatican embassies around the world. The collection for the fund occurs each year around June 29, the feast of Sts. Peter and Paul.
However, several reports in recent years have alleged that only a small portion of the money received annually was used for charity while the majority of the contributions were used to fill the gap in the Vatican’s administrative budget.
More recently, in September, questions arose as to whether funds from the Peter’s Pence collection were used to finance the Vatican Secretariat of State’s purchase of a majority stake in a property in London’s Chelsea district, a purchase which incurred major debts.
Cardinal Angelo Becciu, the former prefect of the Congregation for Saints’ Causes who was asked by Pope Francis to resign amid an investigation into alleged financial mismanagement, denied that Peter’s Pence funds were used to purchase the London property; the money, he said, came from a fund within the Secretariat of State.
However, when asked by a journalist Sept. 25 if the money in the Secretariat of State fund came from Peter’s Pence, Becciu said, “Yes.”
Guerrero, who was appointed to lead the Secretariat for the Economy in 2020, called the London deal “a painful history” and said that while it was common to gain or lose from an investment, “there were irregularities; we must understand them and punish those responsible.”
“The investments of the Peter’s Pence collection traditionally were included with the investments of other funds assigned to the Secretariat of State,” he explained. “It wasn’t easy to say whether this part, these actions or that this building was of Peter’s Pence and this one was from the other funds.”
Nevertheless, Guerrero told Vatican News that complications arising from the London deal have led the Vatican “to embark on a path of transparency, which includes the clarification of unclear” situations.
“What can be said in the meantime is that the devaluation and losses regarding the building in London did not weigh on the Peter’s Pence fund but on other funds held by the Secretariat of State. I believe this was done out of respect for the donations of the faithful,” he said. “This was decided when the amount of each fund’s coverage of the losses was made.”
As of June 20, he said, the Peter’s Pence fund had received 21 million euros ($25.1 million) in donations since the beginning of the year. Of those donations, 8 million euros ($9.5 million) have been donated “to evangelization or social projects to support churches in need, primarily in countries in Africa, Asia and Latin America.”
Guerrero said it also is important to understand that the pope’s “mission of unity in charity” includes the work of the offices of the Roman Curia and nunciatures around the world, which also are supported by Peter’s Pence.
“Let us recall the service of unity in faith of the liturgy, the church’s tribunals, the pope’s communications, the care of the patrimony received throughout two centuries in the library or the archives where documents important to the history of humanity are kept,” he said.
“These services given to the universal church have no income and are financed partially with the Peter’s Pence collection,” Guerrero added.
A portion of the donations also is set aside for investment and savings, he said. “When significant, extraordinary donations come in — for example, a large bequest for the pope’s mission — it does not seem prudent to spend it immediately.”
“Saving in the years when you need it least, for when you need it most, is something sensible and prudent,” the Jesuit said. “Of course, these savings must be administered with care, according to the principles of the church’s social doctrine, with the prudence of a good father of a family, and with the knowledge that what we receive each year does not cover all the expenses of the mission.”