Opinion on abortion’s legality unchanged; some shifting within groups

Opinion on abortion’s legality unchanged; some shifting within groups

Opinion on abortion’s legality unchanged; some shifting within groups

A woman who supports abortion stands alongside pro-life supporters during a June 22, 2018, rally outside the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington. A new Public Religion Research Institute survey of more than 54,000 Americans released Aug. 13, 2019, shows 54% of Americans believe abortion should be legal in all or most cases, while 40% believe it should be illegal in most or all cases, reflecting attitudes little changed from a 2014 survey. But researchers also detected movement in many demographic groups, Catholics included. (Credit: Toya Sarno Jordan/Reuters via CNS.)

While a survey of more than 54,000 Americans showed little change in their attitudes between 2014 and 2018 on the legality of abortion, researchers detected movement in many demographic groups, Catholics included.

Washington, D.C. — While a survey of more than 54,000 Americans showed little change in their attitudes between 2014 and 2018 on the legality of abortion, researchers detected movement in many demographic groups, Catholics included.

Natalie Jackson, director of research for the Public Religion Research Institute, said the changes in attitude reflect the nation’s political divisions.

According to the survey, which was released Aug. 13, 54 percent of Americans believe abortion should be legal in all or most cases, while 40 percent believe it should be illegal in most or all cases. “These numbers are essentially unchanged since 2014,” the survey said; then 55 percent of Americans said abortion should be legal in all or most cases, and 41 percent said it should be illegal in most or all cases.

In an Aug. 12 phone interview with Catholic News Service, the 1 percent change in the overall numbers is not statistically significant, but “everything that we are calling out as differences (from the 2014 survey) are statistically significant,” Jackson said.

Catholics “mirror the rest of the country pretty closely, particularly white Catholics,” she added. Fifty-three percent of white Catholics believe most or all abortions should be legal compared to 40 percent who say most or all should be illegal, Jackson noted, “so they’re right in line” with the majority of Americans.

However, “when you look at Hispanic Catholics, you’re looking at a different picture,” she told CNS. “We pull out the Hispanic and Latino population, because they’re a distinct group. They’re divided heavily by religion and by place of birth. A healthy minority of Hispanics are evangelical, and the PRRI study looked at the attitudes of Hispanics born in the United States, Puerto Rico and Latin America separately.”

“The Hispanic Catholics are a good bit different from white and other nonwhite Catholics that look like the rest of the population as whole,” Jackson said.

Other nonwhite Catholics support abortion’s legality by a 55 percent to 37 percent margin, approximating the views of their white co-religionists. But a majority of Hispanics, 52 percent, believe abortion should be illegal in most or all instances, while 41 percent hold the opposite view.

“White evangelical Protestants and Hispanic Catholics also report becoming more opposed than supportive” of abortion over time, the study said.

Sixteen percent of Hispanic Catholics said they’ve become less supportive of abortion over time, while 11 percent said they’d become more supportive. Among white Catholics, 8 percent said they’re now more supportive, but 9 percent report growing less supportive.

Among other nonwhite Catholics, 13 percent say they’ve grown more supportive of abortion, as opposed to 9 percent who say they’re now less supportive.

The survey, according to Jackson, did not ask the time frame in which they had changed their views, or the circumstances behind the change. The interview subjects from 2014 are not the same from 2018.

Survey respondents were also asked whether they would vote only for candidates who share their views on abortion. Among those for whom it made a difference, the percentages favored Catholic demographic groups who believe more or all abortions should be illegal.

For white Catholics, the split was 27 percent-15 percent. For Hispanic Catholics, the difference was 30 percent – 17 percent. For other nonwhite Catholics, the margin was 15 percent-14 percent.

The Catholic Church teaches abortion is morally wrong, upholding the sanctity of life from contraception to natural death.

“Solid majorities of all major religious groups in the U.S. support government-backed health insurance programs covering contraceptives,” the survey results said. “Those numbers decline among all religious groups on support for covering abortion, with the considerable variance between only 22 percent support from white evangelical Protestants and 80 percent support among Unitarian Universalists.”

Support for legal abortion was particularly strong in the northeastern United States — New York, New Jersey, Maryland, Delaware and the six New England states — each registering at least 61 percent support for legal abortion in most or all cases. White Catholics, meanwhile, have their strongest representation in the Northeast, with 20 percent of its white residents professing to be Catholic, according to PRRI.

“Although a few states such as Alabama and Missouri have recently passed laws that — should they survive court challenges — would make abortion illegal with virtually no exceptions,” the survey said, “there is no state in which more than one-quarter of residents say abortion should be illegal in all cases.”

The survey was conducted by phone between Jan. 3 and Dec. 30, 2018, among 54,357 respondents, 60 percent of them contacted via cellphone. At least 1,000 interviews were conducted each week. Interviewers asked to speak to the youngest adult living in the household. The margin of error for the total survey is 0.4 percentage points.


Crux is dedicated to smart, wired and independent reporting on the Vatican and worldwide Catholic Church. That kind of reporting doesn’t come cheap, and we need your support. You can help Crux by giving a small amount monthly, or with a onetime gift. Please remember, Crux is a for-profit organization, so contributions are not tax-deductible.

Latest Stories

Most Read

Crux needs your monthly support

to keep delivering the best in smart, wired and independent Catholic news.

Latest Stories