Pope Leo XIV at the Vatican's General Audience in St. Peter's Square, Nov. 18, 2026. (Credit: Vatican Media.)
Pope Leo XIV at the Vatican's General Audience in St. Peter's Square, Nov. 18, 2026. (Credit: Vatican Media.)

Can Pope Leo XIV finally get a handle on the abuse crisis that has overshadowed the Catholic Church for decades?

During his Wednesday General Audience, he mentioned abuse twice. First, he spoke about it in his main speech about his apostolic journey to South America, mentioning that he met personally with victims of abuse.

He also made an appeal at the end of the audience, mentioning that Nov. 18 is the National Day of Prayer for Victims and Survivors of Abuse in Italy, which is organized by the National Service for the Protection of Minors and Vulnerable Adults of the Italian Episcopal Conference.

“The theme, ‘Listening that heals, communities that rebuild’, reminds us that, for the Christian community, the prevention and countering of abuse is a way of living out evangelical conversion, starting by listening to those who have been hurt, calling evil by its name and embarking on paths of truth, justice and reconstruction,” Pope Leo said.

The pontiff spoke about this on the plane when returning from Peru, when asked about “spiritual abuse” in the Church.

He said spiritual abuse is a “very serious” topic.

“It is being studied in the Vatican. There’s not an immediate document as such to be published. Well… yet,” he said.

RELATED: On plane from Peru, Pope Leo emphasizes unity in the Church

“But the concept itself, the need to be able to address some of those issues canonically, which is one of the problems because in order to exercise justice, you have to have a, if you will, a codification or a juridical expression of how to apply that. And that’s a very vague concept still,” the pope added. “Although we all probably could describe either specific cases or kinds of instances where that has happened.”

When he was still Bishop Robert Francis Prevost, he led the Diocese of Chiclayo in Peru from 2015 to 2023, having served as administrator from 2014. He had served as a missionary in Peru for over a decade, beginning in 1985.

After his meeting with abuse victims in Lima, Peru, on November 12, the advocacy group SNAP (Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests) called on Pope Leo to make public the records on sexual abuse victims in Peru.

“Abusers must be immediately removed and the Vatican’s abuse archives should be made public,” said Angela Walker, SNAP’s executive director, two days after the meeting. She had stood with protestors outside the Holy See’s Apostolic Nunciature on the day the pope’s meeting with victims took place.

The abuse crisis has plagued the Catholic Church since the 1980s, when the Diocese of Lafayette, Louisiana, was accused of covering up abuse. SNAP was created in 1988. In the United States, it became a national crisis when The Boston Globe‘s “Spotlight” team published its series on clerical abuse in the city’s archdiocese in 2002. This led to a meeting of U.S. cardinals with Pope St. John Paul II in April 2002 and the creation of the “Dallas Charter” on the sexual abuse of minors.

(Crux was founded by The Boston Globe in 2014, before becoming independent in 2016.)

The series highlighted issues that have affected the Catholic Church, both at the local level and at the Vatican itself.

RELATED: The Vatican still hasn’t learned how to deal with abuse allegations

First, secrecy surrounding investigations into abuse allegations often harms the victims and the Church, whose faithful are scandalized and whose leaders have lost moral credibility.

Second, Church leaders still often follow the same playbook they used throughout the darkest decades of the sexual abuse crisis.

The playbook includes therapy, clergy moves, and payoffs. It also includes turning a blind eye, victim-blaming and intimidation, minimization, obfuscation, and even outright denial.

Pope Leo inherited this problem. Even the Vatican itself is facing the case against Father Marko Rupnik. The former Jesuit is accused of abusing adult women, but his alleged victims claim they have faced this obfuscation. Laura Sgrò, the lawyer for five alleged victims, said her clients hadn’t even been told whether the trial had begun.

Bishop Christopher Saunders in Australia was convicted of abusing two young Indigenous men in August. Bishop Andrzej Jeż in Poland was convicted in October of failing to report allegations of sexual abuse of minors involving two priests.

Speaking to Crux Now’s Elise Ann Allen last year, Pope Leo said the Church is in “kind of a bind there,” in helping victims and also protecting the presumption of innocence given to those accused of abuse.

RELATED: Pope Leo tells Crux’s Elise Ann Allen about Vatican finances and clerical abuse

“The Church certainly has tried to make new legislation that would both speed up the process, would respect especially the issues that I was speaking of earlier, the victims and their pain and their right to have that pain recognized in some kind of response from the church, but at the same time the respect of the accused,” he said. “The protection of the rights of the accused party is also an issue.”

Leo said it is a “really difficult” thing to care for, “because someone who has had their lives oftentimes deeply wounded or even destroyed by sexual abuse, only can feel that.”

“There are many other people in the Church who also have a right to be accompanied in whatever they are living and experiencing, and the Church has to be with them as well,” the pope said last year. “It’s one more of the many challenges that I’m trying to find a way to deal with.”

This is the challenge the Holy Father faces early in his pontificate.

On the plane trip back to Rome on Monday, Pope Leo mentioned the character he brings from being from the United States.

“In many ways, I’m a gringo, a North American,” he said. “I think that, among other things, when I say something, I say it plainly and directly.”

The abuse crisis in the Catholic Church is not going away, and Pope Leo needs to embrace this plainness and directness to tackle it.

Pope Leo gave evidence that he is willing to do this in the interview with Crux Now.

“Statistics show that well over 90 percent of people who come forward and make accusations, they are authentically victims,” he said last year. “They are not making this up.”

Follow Charles Collins on X: @CharlesinRome

Charles Collins is Editor-in-Chief of Crux and an expert in Vatican affairs. A native Texan now living in the United Kingdom, he spent almost 15 years in Rome. From 2001 to 2017, Collins worked in Vatican...