WASHINGTON, D.C. — Nearly nine in 10 Catholics surveyed said they want their donations to church institutions to be ethically invested and a majority of those responding voiced particular opposition to investments in companies that produce pornography, tobacco products and e-cigarettes, according to a new survey.
The survey for Boston-based Catholic Investment Services found that about 87 percent of respondents would be more likely to donate to Catholic institutions if they knew the money would be invested in ways consistent with church teaching and values.
In contrast, about 14 percent of respondents said ethical investing was not a consideration when donating to Catholic institutions.
The results parallel those of a CIS survey released in April. Peter Jeton, the firm’s outgoing CEO, said the new study sought to more specifically identify what investments motivate or deter Catholics to give to church entities.
People want their donations to go “where it’s good and avoid evil,” Jeton said.
“Ethical investing can be a motivating factor in how much people give,” he told Catholic News Service. “And if I am the CFO (chief financial officer) of a diocese or if I’m the bishop of a diocese, then I should be explaining very clearly and with frequency what the policy is regarding how people’s money is being invested.”
The survey involved 500 Catholic adults who answered a series of online questions Sept. 7-9. It has a margin of error of plus or minus 4.5 percentage points.
It covered more than a dozen types of businesses — from manufacturers of medications used during an abortion procedure to oil and natural gas mining — to which respondents voiced objections.
In the case of the pornography industry, 60% of respondents said church money should not be invested in such endeavors. Opposition also was raised to investing in tobacco products and e-cigarettes (57 percent), alcoholic beverages (52 percent), medications used during an abortion (52 percent), casinos and gaming (51 percent), medical facilities where abortions occur (50 percent), gun manufacturing (47 percent), for-profit prisons/detention centers (45 percent), security, defense and large-scale weapons (44 percent), research on embryonic stem cells (37 percent), manufacturers of birth control (31 percent) and oil and natural gas extraction (30 percent).
Jeton suggested that institutional financial officers and bishops be fully transparent about their investment decisions. “The better the engagement, the better for the Church,” he said.
“They should emphasize the link with Catholic social teaching,” he added. “Because if our data is correct, then making people in the pews aware of that should, by all rights, increase the comfort level with the Church and a greater willingness to share more of their financial resources with the Church.”
The survey also asked participants what investments Catholic institutions should be making. Among those cited by respondents were clean air and water (67 percent), workforce education/job training (66 percent), education technology (65 percent), agriculture and food (65 percent), health care providers (62 percent), affordable housing (60 percent), recycling (57 percent), renewable energy (53 percent), land conservation (50 percent), fitness/nutrition (49 percent) and banking and financial services to low-income people and small businesses (46 percent).
Catholic Investment Services was founded in 2013 to serve Catholic entities, including dioceses, colleges and universities, hospital systems and social service agencies. Jeton said the firm follows the socially responsible investment guidelines adopted by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops.
Those guidelines, in place since 2003, are divided into six broad categories: protecting human life, promoting human dignity, reducing arms production, pursuing economic justice, protecting the environment and encouraging corporate responsibility. Each category lists specific areas of concern, such as abortion, racial discrimination, labor standards and other social needs in which the Church has had a voice.
Jeton said he hoped the data developed would influence how diocesan bishops in particular discuss finances with “the folks in the pew.”
“They would do well to pay attention to mechanisms that would get more people engaged,” Jeton said. “Hopefully with greater engagement there is growing willingness (among donors) to go into their back pocket to help the Church.”
Crux is dedicated to smart, wired and independent reporting on the Vatican and worldwide Catholic Church. That kind of reporting doesn’t come cheap, and we need your support. You can help Crux by giving a small amount monthly, or with a onetime gift. Please remember, Crux is a for-profit organization, so contributions are not tax-deductible.